Y mae gennyf gryn dipyn o barch at Dafydd Wigley, cyn Aelod Seneddol Caernarfon. Yn anffodus yr oedd ei gyfraniad i raglen Gwilym Owen heddiw ymhell o fod yn un o glasuron deallusol Dafydd. Bwrdwn neges Dafydd oedd fod angen galw refferendwm am bwerau'r Cynulliad fis Medi neu Hydref 2010 oherwydd y byddai 'na lywodraeth Geidwadol mewn grym erbyn hynny. Mewn geiriau eraill y mae cyn ddisgybl Ysgol Rydal yn parhau i gredu mae'r unig ffordd i sicrhau mwy o bwerau i'r Cynulliad fyddai cynnal pleidlais, nid ar addasrwydd y cynigion ar gyfer pwerau'r Cynulliad, ond yn hytrach ar sail rhyw fath o ryfel dosbarth yn erbyn y Blaid Geidwadol.
Y mae gennyf neges syml iawn i Dafydd. Os am ddenu cefnogaeth i bwerau rhesymol fyddai'n rhoi trefn ar ddeddf wallus Llywodraeth Cymru 2006 yna fe fydd angen cefnogaeth o bob rhan o Gymru a chan bob math o unigolion sy'n digwydd byw i'r gorllewin o Glawdd Offa. Os mae bwriad Dafydd a'i debyg yw cynnal pleidlais am hawl y Ceidwadwyr i fod yn llywodraethu yn San Steffan, a thrwy hynny ddylanwadu ar lywodraeth Cymru, yna fe fydd y posibilrwydd o greu partneriaeth draws bleidiol i wared Cymru o effeithiau negyddol deddf 2006 yn llawer anoddach.
Un pwynt arall. Fel gwleidydd profiadol a deallus fe ddylai Dafydd ddeall nad oes modd cynnal pleidlais ar 'bwerau'r Alban' o fewn y setliad cyfansoddiadol fel y mae'n bodoli. Y mae awgrymu y dylid cael geiriad i'r cwestiwn ar sail yr angen am bwerau tebyg i'r Alban unai yn dangos diffyg gonestrwydd neu diffyg dealltwriaeth. O 'nabod Dafydd ni chredaf ei fod yn cam ddeall y sefyllfa felly trist yw gorfod dod i'r casgliad ei fod yn bod yn fwriadol anonest yn ei sylwadau am 'bwerau'r Alban'.
I have a lot of respect for Dafydd Wiglesy, the retired MP for Caernarfon. Unfortunately his contribution to the devolution debate made today on the Gwilym Owen programme on Radio Cymru were not his finest hour. Dafydd basically wants a referendum on further powers for the Assembly to be held in September or October 2010 because he feels that there will be a Conservative Government at Westminster by that point. In other words it would appear that the Rydal School educated Wigley wants to play class war against the Conservative Party rather than arguing his case for further powers for the Assembly on the merits of the proposals.
I have a simple message for Dafydd. If you want to attract support for a meaningful review of the current constitutional mess that we have in Wales as a result of the Government of Wales Act 2006 then you will need to attract support from all parts of Wales and from all of us who happen to live west of Offa's Dyke. If, rather than arguing his case, Dafydd prefers the option of a referendum on the right of the Conservative Party to govern then he will destroy any opportunity to create a consensus in Wales on how the Assembly should serve the people of Wales. Is that his intention?
One final point. Dafydd also stated more than once that the people of Wales should be asked whether they want the same powers as Scotland has. He is either being dishonest or fails to understand the current constitutional question. In simple terms the option of a referendum on 'powers similar to Scotland' is simply not on offer. To continue to talk about a vote on such an option is less than honest.
Guto